Over and over again I am moved by your humanity and your crystal clear thinking. This is a brilliant piece. Or should I say this is another brilliant piece.
Reading Bret Stephens piece in the New York Times of Oct 21, it was refreshing to read the comments section. Many if not most of the commentators disagreed with Stephens arguments.
“One can understand Mr. Mamdani's sentiments, even if they seem too extreme for Bret Stephens, given the overwhelming injustice that has been meted out to Palestinians by Israeli Jews.
Mr. Mamdani, as Mr. Stephens notes, is not antisemitic, but he is fiercely anti-Zionist. No Jew living in the United States has cause to fear that.
What I and many other American Jews fear is the antisemitic sentiment fueled by Israel's war crimes.
One must not conflate Israel's war crimes with Judaism or with all Jews, but there will always be haters and weak minds who will.”
Bret Stevens recently denied the genocide in Israel with no apparent qualifications or actual research to do so. This denial was in the face of declarations by qualified organizations and scholars charging Israel with genocide. If the table was turned and a columnist denied the genocide in Nazi Germany, in the face of the empirical evidence showing otherwise, that columnist would be declared a bigot. If Stevens is looking for a bigot, he need look no further than his mirror.
Cheeto And His Billionaire Allies Attack America’s Welfare State
Investing in people with less financial means pays off in higher graduation rates for kids, higher rates of moving onto higher education, less crime, and more stable communities And like it or not, America has provided for those with less means for almost a century since the Great Depression As troubling as it is, there is a definite possibility in food insecurity in this country
So Cheeto and his Nazi allies/billionaire buddies have decided that the time is up for all these welfare recipients because the Nazi party has decided that they’re tired of this “gimme” welfare state And just like the ACA(Obamacare) fiasco, the Nazis wanted to get rid of the ACA but had no plan with which to replace it, the Nazis want to destroy the welfare safety net and food security for those less fortunate because those “takers” don’t deserve it and don’t know how to replace with another plan
This Nazi approach toward the welfare state mirrors the cruelty toward the immigrant population as demonstrated by ICE but this time the cruelty is lodged toward the less fortunate of our society So yes the Nazi party is cruel and insensitive to the needs of those who need our help The Cheeto’s, Stephen Miller’s and Nazis of the world do not deserve our vote Get rid of all of them!!
Absolute logic deconstructs absolutely the false narratives bandied about with impunity. Thank you once again Peter for your transparent and crystal clear analysis. Simply brilliant clarity!
Such unfounded accusations can only give support to the true Antisemite that the Jewish national leadership business and rabbis only concern and loyalty is to Israel. Such unfortunate positions only feed the issue of dual loyalty. Too bad for the Jewish community too bad for the people of NYC who now knows that Jews don’t care about them and the city but about Israel .
Thank you Peter for exposing the phony attacks for what they are. It's a shame that so-called liberal media has done such a pitiful job at doing what you have accomplished in this piece. Are they all running so scared for their jobs? Do you have their own version of ICE policing their columnists? I would love to know why there appears to be such profound collusion with the Israelhasarighttodefenditself mob.
Shkoyach Peter! Zohran Mamdani doesn’t have an antisemitic bone in his body. And it is imperative for NYC Yiddin to reject the obscene, baseless hatred being directed at him the by the powers that be in New York and the Trump regime.
He loves New York and all of its residents, and he is always in a “New York State of Mind.” He’s hot shit and he killed it, last week, at the NYC mayoral debate.
Mamdani is a true patriot and solid rock in a country that is rotting, morally, at the core. He is a man of direction and conviction in a nation that, at last for the time being, has lost its way and its honor.
He is a key liberator of a country whose cites and citizens, in certain instances, are now fully occupied by barbarians and Brownshirts in their own federal government.
And he is a modern day Robin Hood who will help put an end to the tech billionaire oligarchs financial exploitation of, and undue influence over, the American people.
Hence, on the morning of Wednesday, November 5, 2025, we are all going to wake up to Zohran Mamdani being the mayor-elect and soon-to-be mayor of “The City That Never Steeps.” “Start spreading the news!”
Over and over again I am moved by your humanity and your crystal clear thinking. This is a brilliant piece. Or should I say this is another brilliant piece.
Spot on, Peter!
Another brilliant piece, Peter. Thank you.
What aboutism is an old tactic and is being used here in plenty.
Reading Bret Stephens piece in the New York Times of Oct 21, it was refreshing to read the comments section. Many if not most of the commentators disagreed with Stephens arguments.
One commentator wrote;
“One can understand Mr. Mamdani's sentiments, even if they seem too extreme for Bret Stephens, given the overwhelming injustice that has been meted out to Palestinians by Israeli Jews.
Mr. Mamdani, as Mr. Stephens notes, is not antisemitic, but he is fiercely anti-Zionist. No Jew living in the United States has cause to fear that.
What I and many other American Jews fear is the antisemitic sentiment fueled by Israel's war crimes.
One must not conflate Israel's war crimes with Judaism or with all Jews, but there will always be haters and weak minds who will.”
Bret Stevens recently denied the genocide in Israel with no apparent qualifications or actual research to do so. This denial was in the face of declarations by qualified organizations and scholars charging Israel with genocide. If the table was turned and a columnist denied the genocide in Nazi Germany, in the face of the empirical evidence showing otherwise, that columnist would be declared a bigot. If Stevens is looking for a bigot, he need look no further than his mirror.
Cheeto And His Billionaire Allies Attack America’s Welfare State
Investing in people with less financial means pays off in higher graduation rates for kids, higher rates of moving onto higher education, less crime, and more stable communities And like it or not, America has provided for those with less means for almost a century since the Great Depression As troubling as it is, there is a definite possibility in food insecurity in this country
So Cheeto and his Nazi allies/billionaire buddies have decided that the time is up for all these welfare recipients because the Nazi party has decided that they’re tired of this “gimme” welfare state And just like the ACA(Obamacare) fiasco, the Nazis wanted to get rid of the ACA but had no plan with which to replace it, the Nazis want to destroy the welfare safety net and food security for those less fortunate because those “takers” don’t deserve it and don’t know how to replace with another plan
This Nazi approach toward the welfare state mirrors the cruelty toward the immigrant population as demonstrated by ICE but this time the cruelty is lodged toward the less fortunate of our society So yes the Nazi party is cruel and insensitive to the needs of those who need our help The Cheeto’s, Stephen Miller’s and Nazis of the world do not deserve our vote Get rid of all of them!!
Absolute logic deconstructs absolutely the false narratives bandied about with impunity. Thank you once again Peter for your transparent and crystal clear analysis. Simply brilliant clarity!
Such unfounded accusations can only give support to the true Antisemite that the Jewish national leadership business and rabbis only concern and loyalty is to Israel. Such unfortunate positions only feed the issue of dual loyalty. Too bad for the Jewish community too bad for the people of NYC who now knows that Jews don’t care about them and the city but about Israel .
Thank you Peter for this great analysis.
Thank you Peter for exposing the phony attacks for what they are. It's a shame that so-called liberal media has done such a pitiful job at doing what you have accomplished in this piece. Are they all running so scared for their jobs? Do you have their own version of ICE policing their columnists? I would love to know why there appears to be such profound collusion with the Israelhasarighttodefenditself mob.
Beware of false shepherds who lead their flock with a staff of fear.
Thank you
Shkoyach Peter! Zohran Mamdani doesn’t have an antisemitic bone in his body. And it is imperative for NYC Yiddin to reject the obscene, baseless hatred being directed at him the by the powers that be in New York and the Trump regime.
He loves New York and all of its residents, and he is always in a “New York State of Mind.” He’s hot shit and he killed it, last week, at the NYC mayoral debate.
Mamdani is a true patriot and solid rock in a country that is rotting, morally, at the core. He is a man of direction and conviction in a nation that, at last for the time being, has lost its way and its honor.
He is a key liberator of a country whose cites and citizens, in certain instances, are now fully occupied by barbarians and Brownshirts in their own federal government.
And he is a modern day Robin Hood who will help put an end to the tech billionaire oligarchs financial exploitation of, and undue influence over, the American people.
Hence, on the morning of Wednesday, November 5, 2025, we are all going to wake up to Zohran Mamdani being the mayor-elect and soon-to-be mayor of “The City That Never Steeps.” “Start spreading the news!”
Masterful.
Thank you Peter
Good points, thanks Peter.