Professor Beinart, I am extremely disappointed. If I were a Palestinian I would be even more disappointed. Everyone knows that Hamas charter is dedicated to killing and specifically killing Jews wherever they are. Any Palestinian who identifies with Hamas, oops let me correct myself, any person who identifies or supports Hamas is in fact…
Professor Beinart, I am extremely disappointed. If I were a Palestinian I would be even more disappointed. Everyone knows that Hamas charter is dedicated to killing and specifically killing Jews wherever they are. Any Palestinian who identifies with Hamas, oops let me correct myself, any person who identifies or supports Hamas is in fact a supporter of Nazism. A supporter of a racial war against Jews.
If Palestinians were to fully support Hamas, there is no way they will achieve a Palestine in the West Bank let alone a Palestine from the River to the Sea. I understand that in the West Bank many do support them, but I attribute that support to the inaction and failure of the Palestinian Authority.
The Hamas charter has much to say about Jews. Here is one quote “"The Day of Judgement will not come about until Moslems fight the Jews (killing the Jews), when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say O Moslems, O Abdulla, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him. Only the Gharkad tree, (evidently a certain kind of tree) would not do that because it is one of the trees of the Jews." (related by al-Bukhari and Moslem). “
If this is the face of Palestinians with regards to Israel and Jews then Israel is justified in destroying Hamas and all who support it. Why wait till they gain enough strength to deliver on their threats?
My point here is simply to differentiate legitimate Palestinian interest in statehood from those people who advocate another genocide of the Jews.
Another point that needs to be stated is that Gaza is not the West Bank. Israel withdrew completely form Gaza. In fact, it left an agricultural industry intact for Gazans to pursue and the world banking community was ready to invest in Gaza including Israel. But that did not happen because Hamas took over and decided to continue its genocidal mission. We hear how Gaza is a prison managed by Israel and how goods and services are blocked from entering Gaza. The truth? The only goods that were blocked were dual use goods that could be turned into armaments or tunnels. So, for example, Israel stopped sending cement to Gaza because instead of building housing for the people there the lion’s share of it was used to build tunnels. (and by the way Egypt shares a border with Gaza too).
I am not thrilled at Israel bombing Gaza. But I do find it odd when I saw on TV a Gazan complain that Israel stopped warning Gazans when they bomb. In the past Israel has called occupants of buildings they were about to destroy and tell them to get out. I found it odd, somehow Hamas didn’t let the civilians it killed, raped, beheaded, or kidnapped know in advance that they were coming, and they should get out of the way. And that is because that is exactly what they wanted to do.
Professor Beinart on your website is a lead article that appears on the right on my screen that claims if Hamas were eliminated nothing would change. A cheap shot would be to say tell that to the communities bordering Gaza. The reality is when genocidal Palestinian groups are eliminated so too is the toxic atmosphere they bring with them, making it possible for Israel and Palestinians who want to live in a Palestinian state (not from the River to the Sea) to discuss a solution approach.
Untold main and Injured Palestinians shot by snipers
because you use fighter Jets Apache helicopters does not absolve you of all these deaths. you are no different then Hamas actions. you are actually worse. all the violence would stop if you zionist would actually want peace more then you want the land. Shame on you for wanting revenge. you want to kill hamas kill them. It will make no difference. When you deny people there freedom they will fight for it. and when you are much weaker they will you terrorisms. you reap what you sow. Peter is right hamas or no hamas violence will be part of your racists life . Those numbers are only Gaza since hamas took over. what did you thinks was going to happen? they were going to cower to the fanatical zionist.
Professor Beinart, I am extremely disappointed. If I were a Palestinian I would be even more disappointed. Everyone knows that Hamas charter is dedicated to killing and specifically killing Jews wherever they are. Any Palestinian who identifies with Hamas, oops let me correct myself, any person who identifies or supports Hamas is in fact a supporter of Nazism. A supporter of a racial war against Jews.
If Palestinians were to fully support Hamas, there is no way they will achieve a Palestine in the West Bank let alone a Palestine from the River to the Sea. I understand that in the West Bank many do support them, but I attribute that support to the inaction and failure of the Palestinian Authority.
The Hamas charter has much to say about Jews. Here is one quote “"The Day of Judgement will not come about until Moslems fight the Jews (killing the Jews), when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say O Moslems, O Abdulla, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him. Only the Gharkad tree, (evidently a certain kind of tree) would not do that because it is one of the trees of the Jews." (related by al-Bukhari and Moslem). “
If this is the face of Palestinians with regards to Israel and Jews then Israel is justified in destroying Hamas and all who support it. Why wait till they gain enough strength to deliver on their threats?
My point here is simply to differentiate legitimate Palestinian interest in statehood from those people who advocate another genocide of the Jews.
Another point that needs to be stated is that Gaza is not the West Bank. Israel withdrew completely form Gaza. In fact, it left an agricultural industry intact for Gazans to pursue and the world banking community was ready to invest in Gaza including Israel. But that did not happen because Hamas took over and decided to continue its genocidal mission. We hear how Gaza is a prison managed by Israel and how goods and services are blocked from entering Gaza. The truth? The only goods that were blocked were dual use goods that could be turned into armaments or tunnels. So, for example, Israel stopped sending cement to Gaza because instead of building housing for the people there the lion’s share of it was used to build tunnels. (and by the way Egypt shares a border with Gaza too).
I am not thrilled at Israel bombing Gaza. But I do find it odd when I saw on TV a Gazan complain that Israel stopped warning Gazans when they bomb. In the past Israel has called occupants of buildings they were about to destroy and tell them to get out. I found it odd, somehow Hamas didn’t let the civilians it killed, raped, beheaded, or kidnapped know in advance that they were coming, and they should get out of the way. And that is because that is exactly what they wanted to do.
Professor Beinart on your website is a lead article that appears on the right on my screen that claims if Hamas were eliminated nothing would change. A cheap shot would be to say tell that to the communities bordering Gaza. The reality is when genocidal Palestinian groups are eliminated so too is the toxic atmosphere they bring with them, making it possible for Israel and Palestinians who want to live in a Palestinian state (not from the River to the Sea) to discuss a solution approach.
o All you racists zionist.
2008 1200 Palestinians 13 Jews
2012 150 Palestinians 6 Jews
2014 2200 Palestinians 67 Jews
2018 175 Palestinians 0 Jews
2021 200 Palestinians 10 Jews
Untold main and Injured Palestinians shot by snipers
because you use fighter Jets Apache helicopters does not absolve you of all these deaths. you are no different then Hamas actions. you are actually worse. all the violence would stop if you zionist would actually want peace more then you want the land. Shame on you for wanting revenge. you want to kill hamas kill them. It will make no difference. When you deny people there freedom they will fight for it. and when you are much weaker they will you terrorisms. you reap what you sow. Peter is right hamas or no hamas violence will be part of your racists life . Those numbers are only Gaza since hamas took over. what did you thinks was going to happen? they were going to cower to the fanatical zionist.